Living Vegan In Charlotte, NC – Easy Vegan Recipes – Vegan Restaurant, Product, and Cookbook Reviews

So I Hung Out With Seitan In The Kitchen And Came Up With One H*ll Of A Good Vegan Philly “Steak” Sandwich

Vegan Philly Steak Sandwich

Vegan Philly Steak Sandwich

This vegan Philly Steak Sandwich is a tribute to my dad. My parents divorced when I was very young.  My dad wanted to remain a major part of my life so, in addition to other time spent with me, we developed a routine of having lunch or dinner together once a week.

In my preteens and teens, we dined at now forgotten restaurants like Tuesday’s (Est. 1865 – Unique Dining in 19th Century Decor!) at the now-demolished Eastland Mall.  I think I liked the art deco atmosphere (the Tiffany lamps, the Alphonse Mucha posters) as much as the food!

In my twenties, we lunched at Bennigan’s, which was conveniently located beside the real estate agency I worked for. (Both Bennigan’s and that real estate office are long, long gone as well).

These places were known for “gourmet” sandwiches, and I wasn’t veg in my teens and twenties.  So my lunch of choice was nearly always a Reuben (sold at Tuesdays for $2.25!) or some sort of a French Dip, grinder, or Philly Cheese Steak, preferably loaded with grilled onions, peppers, and mushrooms.

So, this Saturday when I found myself hanging out in the kitchen with seitan, I knew EXACTLY what I wanted to make.


1 package Upton’s Naturals Traditional Seitan (This comes in chunks suitable for a stew or stir-fry; for this sandwich I sliced it into smaller, thinner bites with a kitchen shears.)

1 Tablespoon Olive Oil

1 medium Yellow Onion, sliced very thin

2 large cloves Garlic, minced

1 medium Green Bell Pepper, sliced

8 oz. Sliced Fresh Button Mushrooms

2 Tablespoons Vegan Worcestershire Sauce

1/3 Cup Dry Red Wine

1/2 Cup Vegetable Broth

1/2 Teaspoon Sea Salt, or to taste

Freshly ground Black Pepper, to taste


6 Hoagie Buns


Preheat the oven to 425 and prep your veggies!  Once you start cooking everything gets thrown in the skillet rather quickly, so go ahead and slice all your veggies now.

Heat a tablespoon of olive oil in a large skillet on medium-high heat. Add the seitan and brown on both sides, approximately 3 minutes.  Add the garlic and onions and saute for another 2-3 minutes.  (You may need to add a little more oil to keep the garlic and onions from burning.)

Add the mushrooms, green peppers, Worcestershire sauce, red wine, and veggie broth.  Cook for about ten minutes, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms have “shrunk” and most of the cooking liquid has evaporated. Taste; add salt if needed and a good grinding of fresh black pepper.

Vegan Philly Steak Sandwich Ingredients

Take the hoagie buns and “hollow out” the thickest part of the bun to make room for the seitan mixture.

Vegan Philly Steak Sandwich Bun

Slather half of the bun with Vegenaise. (You’ll want to be generous; Vegenaise, when heated, actually becomes a little “cheesy.”)  Then, using a slotted spoon to drain extra liquid (so your sandwiches won’t be soggy), fill the hoagie buns with the seitan mixture.

Philly Steak Sandwich In The Making

Wrap in aluminum foil and bake in the oven for 15 minutes.

Vegan Philly Steak Sandwich Wrapped

Unwrap, eat, and enjoy!

vegan philly steak sandwich close up

The “cheeselike” substance you see in this photo is actually Vegenaise – it solidifies somewhat when heated and gives you that “cheesy” mouthfeel! A little trick I learned from Zizi’s Awesome Vegan To Go.


  • For the veggie broth I used Better than Bouillon Vegetable Base (their vegetarian Beef Base might also work).  I like Better than Boullion because it allows you to make small amounts of vegetable broth, when you don’t want to open a whole can or box.
  • Why do I recommend Upton’s Naturals Traditional Seitan?  Here’s a big reason why – the ingredients list! Vital wheat gluten, whole wheat flour, water, garlic, sea salt, onion, soy sauce.  

Tagged as: , , , , , , , ,

Categorised in: Sandwiches & Sandwich Fillings, Vegan Recipes

7 Responses »

  1. I’ve never tried seitan… I have a recipe for vegan cheesesteak on my blog with baked tofu. The vegenaise option sounds better than daiya:) again I love the story behind this sandwich:)

  2. I’ve never been a seitan fan but maybe I’ll give it another go. Looks delicious!

  3. where do you get the Upton’s Naturals?


  1. Upton’s Naturals Wrap-Up | VegCharlotte

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Creative Commons License
VegCharlotte - Living Vegan in Charlotte, NC by is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
%d bloggers like this: